Coverage Areas:  National |  South Carolina |  Aiken |  Beaufort |  Charleston |  Columbia |  Greenville |  Myrtle Beach |  Rock Hill
Menu

‘Laudato Si’: What’s the controversy?

Poor Pope Francis. An awful lot of what he says gets misconstrued.

With ‘Laudato Si’, the environmental encyclical, his comments on global warming and air conditioning opened the floodgates. On the first topic, one online source charged him with being a Communist, implying that he advocates totalitarian regulation of fossil fuel use. On the second, the outcry implied that His Holiness wants everyone to spend our summers sizzling.

It’s true that Pope Francis (a trained chemist) acknowledges evidence of climate change. The latest statistics from NOAA (the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration), NASA, the EPA, and WMO (the World Meteorological Organization) show an ongoing trend of rising temperatures and severe weather events. The pope warns that we can anticipate an escalation in the number of environmental refugees if such phenomena as desertification and rise in sea levels come to pass. He does not, however, say that the solution is massive governmental intervention.

The pope notes that resolutions from various World Summits have largely failed and remarks, “We should not think that political efforts or the force of law will be sufficient to prevent actions which affect the environment.” The Church does, we recall, preach the principle of subsidiarity, which means that problems should first be addressed on the local level. Pope Francis says that, in his words, “a real difference” can be made in voluntary actions taken close to home.

For example, individuals can purchase produce at farmers’ markets and roadside stands. Families can develop strategies for conservative use of water, electricity, and disposables. Neighborhoods can repurpose, reuse, and recycle. Towns can pro-rate garbage collection according to volume. States can enact vehicle and industrial emissions inspections and impose limits. All of this can minimize the need for federal legislation or international eco-treaties. The pope cautions that “the internationalization of environmental costs” will cripple poor nations.

The second topic, air conditioning, comes up when Pope Francis addresses our habits of consumption, particularly over-consumption. Father Alexander Lucie-Smith, a Catholic priest writing from the U.K., has offered a good explanation of the pope’s remarks. Quite simply, Father Lucie-Smith says, the pope is concerned that we are over-reliant on air conditioning and use it in ways that exceed our need. The pope himself lives in an apartment which is cooled. We know that air conditioning is essential for urban apartment dwellers in simmering cities. It is also a must for people with heart and respiratory ailments in the midst of heat waves. Sprawling factories and museums and archives need cooling systems to preserve workers and cultural treasures. However, Pope Francis’s remarks lead us to consider that there are cases in which open windows, screen doors, fans, and canopies of shade trees would serve us well.

Throughout the encyclical, the pope steers clear of recommendations that we renounce the modern world. Instead, he asks us to use technology, utilities, land, and water wisely. He challenges us be good stewards of God-given earthly goods.

 

By Sister Pamela Smith, SSCM






  • Diocesan Events Calendar
    View All Events
    Nov 17 Diocese of Charleston Native American Catholic Heritage Celebration
    From the Calendar of Native American Ministry
    Nov 18 Vietnamese Martyrs Celebration
    From the Calendar of Vietnamese Ministry
    Dec 1 Black Catholics Heritage Celebration
    From the Calendar of African American Ministry
    Dec 15 Simbang Gabi for Filipino Catholics
    From the Calendar of Filipino Ministry
    Dec 25 Diocesan Television Christmas Special Fox 21
    From the Calendar of Ethnic Ministries
    Jan 412:00 am Class 2019 Ordination Retreat
    From the Calendar of Diaconate
    Jan 812:00 am Retiro Espiritual de Emmaus
    From the Calendar of Pastoral Juvenil
    Jan 1210:00 am Junta de Equipo Diocesano de Emmaus
    From the Calendar of Pastoral Juvenil
    Feb 911:00 am Ordination of Permanent Deacons
    From the Calendar of Diaconate